The Perfect Grind: Why Your Pressure Gauge is Too Low (Under-Extracted)

As a home barista, few things frustrate more than a Breville pressure too low reading on your machine’s gauge, signaling under-extracted espresso that’s sour, weak, and watery.

This comprehensive guide dives deep into why your Breville Barista Express (or similar models) shows low pressure, how to spot under-extraction, and precise fixes using grind settings, dose weights, and troubleshooting steps to hit the ideal espresso zone.

Understanding the Pressure Gauge

The pressure gauge on Breville machines is your visual cue for brew performance. It’s marked with three zones:

• Pre-infusion zone (left/low): Normal during the first 5-8 seconds
• Espresso zone (middle/grey): Where you want the needle during extraction
• Over-extraction zone (right/high): Indicates too much resistance

What the Numbers Mean

During extraction, you should see:

• Needle starting low during pre-infusion
• Rising into the grey “espresso” band
• Stabilizing around the 9-12 o’clock position
• Some fluctuation is normal

Target pressure: 9-12 bar during active extraction (after pre-infusion)

Why Pressure Matters

Pressure reflects the resistance of your coffee puck against hot water flow:

• Low pressure = Water rushing through too fast
• Result = Under-extraction (sour, thin, watery shots)
• High pressure = Water struggling to flow
• Result = Over-extraction (bitter, harsh shots)

Ideal extraction: 25-30 seconds for a double shot (including 5-8s pre-infusion) yielding approximately 36-40ml (1.5oz)

Pro Tip: Gauges aren’t perfectly calibrated across all machines. Some users report optimal-tasting shots even when the gauge appears in the “over” zone. Taste is the ultimate judge, but the gauge is an excellent starting point.

Signs of Under-Extraction

When your Breville pressure too low, you’ll notice these telltale signs:

Visual Indicators

Sign	What You See
Pour speed	Gushing, fast flow (under 15 seconds)
Color	Blonde, watery, like weak tea
Crema	Thin, pale, disappears quickly
Puck after	Wet, soupy, not firm

Taste Profile

• Sour/acidic - Like lemon juice or unripe fruit
• Thin body - Watery, lacking texture
• Missing sweetness - No caramel or chocolate notes
• Astringent - Dry, mouth-puckering sensation
• Empty finish - Flavor disappears quickly

Shot Characteristics

• Extraction time under 20 seconds
• Yield exceeds 2:1 ratio (40ml+ from 18g dose)
• Gauge needle stays in left zone throughout

Common Causes of Low Pressure

Let’s address the most frequent reasons your pressure gauge stays low:

1. Grind Size Too Coarse

The #1 cause of low pressure. When grounds are too coarse, water flows through with minimal resistance.

Solution: Adjust grind finer in small increments

Breville Grind Dial	Description
1-3	Very fine (usually too fine)
4-6	Fine (start here for most beans)
7-9	Medium-fine (may be too coarse)
10-16	Coarse (too coarse for espresso)

Starting point for most medium roasts: Setting 5-6

Important: Only adjust the grind dial while the grinder is running to prevent burr damage.

2. Dose Too Low

Not enough coffee creates insufficient resistance for proper pressure.

Solution: Increase your dose

Basket Type	Minimum Dose	Ideal Dose
Single (7g)	7g	8-9g
Double (18g)	16g	18-20g

Use a scale - Eyeballing leads to inconsistency. A $15 kitchen scale changes everything.

3. Weak or Uneven Tamp

Inconsistent pressure allows water to find the path of least resistance.

Solution: Apply firm, level pressure

• Target approximately 30 lbs of pressure
• Keep the tamper level (not angled)
• Polish with a slight twist at the end
• Don’t tap the portafilter after tamping

Practice tip: Press your tamper on a bathroom scale until you learn what 30 lbs feels like.

4. Stale Coffee Beans

Fresh beans (2-14 days post-roast) contain CO2 that creates resistance. Stale beans have degassed and compact differently.

Solution: Use fresh beans

• Check the roast date (not “best by” date)
• Use beans within 4 weeks of roasting
• Store in an airtight container
• Avoid pre-ground coffee for espresso

5. Wrong Basket Type

Double-wall (pressurized) baskets create artificial pressure, masking issues. Single-wall baskets require proper technique.

Solution: Know your basket

• Single-wall: Requires precise grind and technique
• Double-wall: Forgiving but limits quality ceiling
• If using single-wall and getting low pressure, focus on grind/dose

Step-by-Step Troubleshooting

Follow this systematic approach to diagnose and fix low pressure:

Step 1: Run a Blank Basket Test

This confirms your machine is working properly:

1. Lock an empty portafilter (no basket) into the group head
2. Place a cup below
3. Run the 2-cup button
4. Watch the pressure gauge

Expected result: Gauge should max out (far right)

If gauge doesn’t max: Potential pump or machine issue (see Machine Issues section)

Step 2: Check Your Grind Size

1. Start at grind setting 5 or 6 for medium roasts
2. Pull a test shot: 18g in, aim for 36g out in 25-30 seconds
3. If too fast (low pressure): Go finer (lower number)
4. Adjust one click at a time
5. Repeat until you hit target extraction time

Step 3: Verify Your Dose

1. Weigh your dose - use a scale every time
2. For double basket: use 18-20g
3. Ensure consistent dosing between shots
4. Too little coffee = not enough resistance

Step 4: Evaluate Your Tamp

1. Distribute grounds evenly before tamping
2. Apply firm, level pressure (30 lbs)
3. Check that the puck surface is flat
4. Don’t tap the portafilter after tamping (causes channeling)

Step 5: Check Bean Freshness

1. Look at the roast date on your bag
2. Beans should be 2-30 days from roast
3. Very fresh beans (under 5 days) may need coarser grind
4. Stale beans (over 30 days) struggle to build pressure

Step 6: Run the Test Shot

After adjustments:

1. Dose 18g of coffee
2. Distribute and tamp evenly
3. Lock portafilter and start extraction immediately
4. Time the shot from button press
5. Target: 25-30 seconds for approximately 36g output

Machine-Related Issues

If technique adjustments don’t help, consider these machine problems:

Worn Group Head Gasket

Symptoms:

• Water leaking around portafilter
• Hissing sound during extraction
• Inconsistent pressure readings
• Portafilter feels loose

Solution: Replace the gasket ($10-15 part)

1. Remove the shower screen
2. Pry out the old gasket with a flathead screwdriver
3. Press new gasket into the groove
4. Reinstall shower screen

Lifespan: Every 2-3 years with regular use

Pump Issues

Symptoms:

• Blank basket test fails
• Weak or no water flow
• Unusual pump sounds
• Inconsistent pressure with good technique

Solution: Service or replace pump

• First, try descaling (scale can affect pump)
• Check warranty coverage
• Contact Breville support
• Professional repair may be needed

Scale Buildup

Symptoms:

• Gradual decline in performance
• Slow flow rate
• Weak steam pressure (also affected)
• Haven’t descaled in months

Solution: Descale the machine

• Follow our descaling guide
• Use Breville solution or citric acid
• Prevention: Use filtered water and regular descaling

Prevention Tips

Keep your pressure in the optimal zone consistently:

Daily Routine

1. Warm up properly: Let machine heat 10-15 minutes
2. Purge before shots: Run water through group head
3. Dose by weight: Use a scale every time
4. Document your shots: Track grind, dose, time, taste

Bean Management

1. Buy fresh, quality beans from local roasters
2. Store in airtight containers away from light
3. Use within 4 weeks of roast date
4. Freeze extras in sealed bags for long-term storage

Machine Maintenance

1. Weekly: Backflush with cleaning tablets
2. Monthly: Descale (adjust for water hardness)
3. Monthly: Clean grinder burrs
4. Quarterly: Inspect gaskets and seals

Grind Best Practices

1. Only adjust while grinder is running
2. Make small adjustments (1-2 clicks)
3. Purge 2-3g after adjustments
4. Recalibrate when changing bean types

FAQs

My gauge stays low even at the finest grind—what now?

First, run the blank basket test to verify your pump is working. If the test passes, ensure you’re using fresh beans and adequate dose (18g+). If the test fails, your machine may need service—check warranty coverage.

What’s the ideal dose for Breville Barista Express double basket?

18 grams is the standard starting point for the single-wall double basket. You can adjust ±2g based on your specific beans and taste preferences.

What grind settings work for light roast coffee?

Light roasts are denser and typically need finer grinds (settings 3-5). They also benefit from slightly higher doses. Expect extraction time may run longer than dark roasts.

Is the pressure gauge accurate?

It’s a visual guide, not a precision instrument. Some machines show optimal taste in the “over-extraction” zone. Prioritize extraction time and taste over needle position—but use the gauge as a reference.

Should I use double-wall or single-wall baskets?

Single-wall for best results once you’ve dialed in your technique. They allow more control and better flavor. Double-wall (pressurized) is forgiving for beginners but limits your espresso quality ceiling.

Key Takeaways

• Low pressure = under-extraction caused by coarse grind, low dose, or weak tamp
• Start here: 18g dose, grind setting 5-6, firm level tamp, 25-30 second extraction
• Adjust one variable at a time to identify the issue
• Fresh beans matter more than any other single factor
• Run a blank basket test to verify machine is working
• Maintenance prevents problems: Descale regularly, replace gaskets every 2-3 years
• The gauge guides, but taste rules - dial iteratively until your espresso tastes balanced

Fixing low pressure is usually as simple as grinding finer. Start there, and work through our troubleshooting steps systematically. You’ll be pulling balanced, flavorful shots in no time.

---

Related Guides:

• Fix High Pressure (Over-Extraction)
• Fix Espresso Channeling
• Complete Descaling Guide